1. Sterling Silver Flatware (Even if It’s Tarnished or Mismatched)

Grandma’s silverware may not match or might be missing a few pieces—but if it’s stamped “Sterling,” it can still be worth good money. Many people confuse silver-plated with sterling, but there’s a big difference in value. Bring it in—tarnish and all.

2. Class Rings 

You might not think twice about that old class ring, but many are made with real gold and can hold surprising value. Even if it’s worn, missing the stone, or from decades ago, it’s worth bringing in. Same goes for old fraternity, sorority, or military academy rings—these often fly under the radar but can bring in a solid return.

3. Old Military Memorabilia

Medals, patches, field gear, or even old photos—these pieces of history are sought after by collectors and museums alike. We’ve seen people shocked to find out how much a few dusty items from a relative’s service could fetch.

4. Pocket Watches (Even Broken Ones!)

A cracked face or missing hands doesn’t mean it’s worthless. Brands like Elgin, Waltham, and Hamilton still hold value—especially in gold-filled or solid gold cases. Collectors love them for parts or restoration.

5. Broken and Unwanted Jewelry

Tangled chains, single earrings, missing stones—none of that means your jewelry has no value. Whether it’s gold, silver, or marked in any way, it’s always worth letting our team take a look. You might be surprised what that bottom-of-the-box piece is actually worth.

The Bottom Line?
Don’t toss it before you let a professional take a look. At Premier Gold, Silver and Coin, we love the thrill of a hidden treasure—and helping you uncover it.